Player Movement Is Changing the NHL’s Definition of Loyalty

Written by Izabela Gage

Player movement has always been part of professional hockey, but the growing number of NHL players requesting trades while still under contract is changing the relationship between players and their organizations. What was once considered an unusual move has become part of a much larger conversation about loyalty, obligations, and how much control players should have over their careers.

Former Colorado Avalanche defenseman Erik Johnson recently criticized the trend, questioning why players are increasingly willing to walk away from commitments they made to their teams.

“I can’t stand these guys halfway through their contracts that they signed in good faith with their team, now bailing ship and wanting to go for greener pastures. … Lots of guys around the league are doing it. I don’t like it,” Johnson said during an ESPN broadcast on Nov. 12.

Teams invest significant money, roster space, and resources into players they expect to build around. When a player requests a trade before that agreement expires, it can leave an organization trying to adjust its plans around a decision it did not necessarily anticipate.

However, the circumstances behind each request can vary significantly.

Johnson experienced this firsthand in Colorado when Matt Duchene requested a trade. Johnson, Gabriel Landeskog, and Nathan MacKinnon approached general manager Joe Sakic to express their commitment to the Avalanche.

“We went to Joe Sakic - we said ‘Get him out of here. We want to be part of the Avs and be part of the solution.’ And we got rewarded for that,” Johnson said.

Duchene was eventually traded to Ottawa in November 2017, while the remaining core continued developing together and ultimately won the Stanley Cup in 2022.

The situation demonstrated that a trade request does not automatically prevent a team from finding long-term success. Colorado was able to move Duchene on its own timeline, securing prospects and draft picks that contributed to its future. Sakic maintained that he would wait for an offer that benefited the organization rather than rush into a deal simply because Duchene wanted out.

A player may want a different situation, but that does not mean a franchise has to sacrifice its own interests to make it happen.

Detroit Red Wings forward Dylan Larkin presents a different perspective. After spending his entire 11-season NHL career with his hometown organization, Larkin requested a trade. His decision was particularly significant because he had been one of the central figures in Detroit’s rebuilding process.

“I asked for a trade from the Detroit Red Wings as the captain, and actions have consequences, and I understand why that decision was made, and I’m going to be professional about it,” Larkin said during his Sept. 17 media availability.

Larkin recognized that requesting a trade can affect how an organization and its supporters view him, showing the personal consequences that can come with asking to leave a team where a player has spent most or all of his career.

Connor Hellebuyck’s departure from Winnipeg further demonstrates why these situations cannot all be viewed the same way. After 11 seasons with the Jets, the three-time Vezina Trophy winner requested a trade before eventually joining the New Jersey Devils in October.

“There were some moments and some things that happened to my family that, for me, crossed the line,” Hellebuyck said during his Nov. 11 media availability in Winnipeg.

Hellebuyck explained that concerns involving his family’s safety, along with uncertainty surrounding his career, contributed to his decision. His situation highlights a side of player movement that is often overlooked when trade requests become discussions about loyalty.

Professional athletes are still employees with families and personal lives outside the rink. Expecting them to remain in an environment they no longer consider suitable simply because they signed a contract ignores the circumstances that can influence those decisions.

The tension surrounding trade requests also involves the way NHL contracts are structured. No-trade and no-movement clauses give players varying degrees of control over where they can be sent, allowing them to reject certain destinations or prevent a trade altogether. Organizations have to agree to include player protections as part of long-term contracts, often in exchange for securing a player’s services.

That distinction became central to the discussion after NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman addressed the recent increase in trade requests during an appearance on Sportsnet’s FAN Hockey Show on Oct. 1.

“I don't think it’s good for the player, I don’t think it’s good for the club, I don’t think it’s good for fans watching and their connection to the game,” Bettman said.

Bettman questioned whether players were using no-trade protections beyond their original purpose by requesting moves while also restricting the teams they would consider joining.

However, NHL Players’ Association executive director Marty Walsh pushed back against that criticism, arguing that players are entitled to exercise protections they negotiated into their contracts.

“It’s the player’s right when they negotiate a contract,” Walsh said during an Oct. 14 interview with Sportsnet.

He pointed out that more than 300 players have some form of trade protection.

The disagreement exposes an important contradiction in the league’s position. Teams want the security of long-term commitments, but they also voluntarily negotiate contracts that give certain players considerable control over their futures.

If organizations believe these clauses give players too much influence, they also have to acknowledge their own role in creating that arrangement. Those protections are part of the agreements teams and players negotiate, meaning the issue is not simply about players exercising power after signing their contracts.

There are consequences to the growing number of requests. A limited list of acceptable destinations can reduce a team’s negotiating options, potentially weakening its return in a trade. Meanwhile, unresolved situations can become distractions for teammates and create tension between players and fan bases.

Hellebuyck’s situation illustrated how those disagreements can continue even after a trade is completed, with Winnipeg coach Scott Arniel publicly expressing disappointment over the goalie’s departure.

Still, the league should be careful about treating every request as an example of players abandoning their commitments. Some are driven by competitive frustration, while others involve personal circumstances that cannot be measured through standings or statistics.

Trade requests are unlikely to disappear, as players aren’t expected to surrender all control over their careers. The more pressing issue is whether the league’s current contractual structure can accommodate that control without creating an imbalance between players and organizations.

Johnson’s frustration speaks to the value of loyalty, but the responses from players and union leadership reveal why loyalty cannot be treated as a one-sided obligation. Teams expect players to honor their contracts, just as players expect organizations to honor the protections and agreements negotiated within them.

The growing number of trade requests may say less about players losing their sense of loyalty and more about a league still adjusting to how much power its players are entitled to have.

Next
Next

A Night for Montreal’s Past, and a Glimpse of Its Future in Net